StyleSk8r
At first rather annoying in its heavy emphasis on reenactments, this movie ultimately proves fascinating, simply because the complicated, highly dramatic tale it tells still almost defies belief.
Dirtylogy
It's funny, it's tense, it features two great performances from two actors and the director expertly creates a web of odd tension where you actually don't know what is happening for the majority of the run time.
BelSports
This is a coming of age storyline that you've seen in one form or another for decades. It takes a truly unique voice to make yet another one worth watching.
zhouw
The plot wasn't special. But I love both the imaginary and the real endings, Nathan&Fi do match very much. The style of editing was very novel in 2006, it's a pretty good TV drama. I hope there would be more ppl to watch it and find its shining Points. Because the show deserve more appreciation. And the style of editing embodied the staffs' ambition, I think they can do more in filmdom. I don't have another word to write.It's wonderful and funny ,I want to watch more TV like that.The roles in this show were all bastard but the Dr.Mani was perfect. The editing made the normal plot became unusual， good. OK. 10 enough,
vikingvampireparrot
I was first drawn in to watch this by the promise of Paul Chequer. I hadn't seen him in anything since As If and was interested to see if he could do anything else. The addition of Jemima Rooper (also from As If) and Navin Chowdry (already shown considerable talent in Teachers and Nylon) made this a must watch.I was not disappointed. Excellently paced with trips and back and forward in time to keep you thinking as well as watching this is the kind of clever drama we should expect to see on BBC3.Inevitably this will be compared with As If and I think it comes off better as a more mature and thoughtful drama focusing on the rights and wrongs of lying to protect others.The ending was brilliant - both sides of the story would have been worthy of an ending and it just shows how small things can change lives. A second series would be welcomed if they can find a way to keep it as fresh and meaningful as the first.
paul_jones-2
Truly, truly an excellent programme. I'm sure I'm too old at 33 for the actual demographic that this programme is aimed at. But having been a fan of the likes of This Life, Green Wing and Teachers etc, it was right up my street.We need Series 2, or at least a Christmas Special!!All the actors are superb and of course Fi is a lovely looking girl. Nathan is an excellent lead and I'm surprised to say I've not seen him before...that is not to say he hasn't been in stuff before, more likely it's me not watching the right things.Come on BBC, let's have another series. There's plenty of story lines that can be followed up and new ones created. Are they happy in Manchester or 200 miles apart? Do Jase and Mani live happily ever after? Does the transsexual get through the operation okay? Do we see the owner of the rabbit again?
manchester_girl
When I saw the trailers for this I thought that it was actually a sequel to As If, as two of the three central cast members are the same. The direction and visual style was pretty identical too, down to the fast edits, playing around with the linear structure, and direct to camera pieces.Despite this, the first episode did have a distinctive, separate tone and identity. It was balanced well between drama and comedy, and although the "twist" was somewhat predictable, it was revealed well by effective time shifts.The characters are all well-rounded and likable, with interesting conflicts. Three main actors all do a great job, especially Jemima Rooper as Fi. I look forward to seeing how it all unravels, and will definitely tune in for episodes 2 and 3.
