Marketic
It's no definitive masterpiece but it's damn close.
GetPapa
Far from Perfect, Far from Terrible
Comwayon
A Disappointing Continuation
Catherina
If you're interested in the topic at hand, you should just watch it and judge yourself because the reviews have gone very biased by people that didn't even watch it and just hate (or love) the creator. I liked it, it was well written, narrated, and directed and it was about a topic that interests me.
robert-temple-1
This Granada TV series of 1972 made an enormous impact at the time with the more discerning viewers in Britain. I remember how many of our friends stayed in on the relevant evening for weeks because they didn't want to miss it. Those people unfamiliar with country life were in a state of severe shock, as this was a series which showed with a high degree of disturbing realism (as with the shocking film THE MILL) just how basic, gruelling, and relentless country life really was early in the 20th century, long before anything remotely resembling modern society existed. It is astonishing to me that so utterly British a series as this should be available on DVD only in America, and that it has never been released in Britain. The series consisted of 13 episodes, each based on a separate short story by either A. E. Coppard or H. E. Bates. Only 8 of the 13 episodes have been included on the DVD release, and the other 5 are omitted, including BREEZE ANSTEY, which was the episode which made the greatest stir at the time of airing. First: CRAVEN ARMS, starring the young Ian McKellen, who delivers a scintillating performance. At the time he was just a young actor, and we did not know how famous he would become. Nor did it seem odd at the time that he kissed the girls. The story is extremely amusing and satirical, about a young man who simply cannot make up his mind which girl he prefers. Second: THE MILL is a real shocker. Rosalind Ayres is truly brilliant as a 17 year-old girl so simple and naive that she doesn't even know how babies are born. Not for one millisecond does she betray in her eyes the slightest hint of worldly wisdom, and this is one of the most successful portrayals of an innocent I have ever seen. She is spurned by her oafish parents and 'goes into service' in a run-down former mill, where the invalid wife who has the dropsy and is confined to bed is played with hysterical guffaws and sheer brilliance by Brenda Bruce. Bad things happen to poor Rosalind, better left unsaid. This is a brutal story about the harsh realities of life in Derbyshire in 1918. Third: THE SULLENS SISTERS. Here we see a wonderful performance by the young Penelope Wilton, now one of Britain's finest mature actresses. Trevor Bannister, later famous in the TV series ARE YOU BEING SERVED?, has a wonderful opportunity to shine in an over-the-top part, and makes the most of it. The well-known actor Peter Firth, aged 21 and playing 19 successfully, is wonderful as an innocent young boy who falls in love with one sister but when he cannot marry her marries the other instead. The story, set in about 1910, is sharply observed, satirical, and realistic. Fourth: Episode 5 (4 is skipped), THE WATERCRESS GIRL. This features an astonishingly brilliant performance by Susan Fleetwood, who became a famous British TV actress but then died tragically at the age of only 51 in 1995 of ovarian cancer. In this story, set in 1908, Fleetwood plays the only child of a single elderly father in an isolated farmhouse beside a river, where she tends a bed of watercress. She has never seen a town and has rarely spoken with anyone. A young carpenter passing by buys some watercress from her, and a long and tragic love affair ensues, in which she has a dead baby and goes to prison for throwing acid in the face of the man's fiancée. This is an exceptionally grim story of country life in the raw. Fifth: Episode 7, THE LITTLE FARM. This is probably the saddest and most tragic of the stories. It features possibly the most brilliant and inspired performance by Bryan Marshall of his entire career, as the illiterate young farmer who has inherited his remote farm from his mother and lives alone there in squalor. He advertises for a female housekeeper. The entire tragedy of this sad story turns upon Marshall's inability to read, which he cleverly disguises in the way we are all so familiar today with dyslexics. Barbara Ewing is excellent as the unhappy young woman who turns up as the housekeeper, trying to escape her own past, and Michael Elphick is sly and wicked as the neighbour who destroys other people's happiness through selfishness, envy and jealousy. The ending is stomach-turning in its pathos. Sixth: Episode 8, THE BLACK DOG, is a tragic and deeply disturbing tale featuring a central performance by Jane Lapotaire which is profound in its insights into the twisted psychology of a girl who cannot love. The Black Dog is the name of a country pub, run by her father. The story is set in 1912, and a young gentleman played by Stephan Chase falls in love compulsively with the strange and enigmatic Lapotaire. The film is haunting, beautifully done, and extremely upsetting. Seventh: Episode 9, THE HIGGLER. This is one of the best of the stories (by Coppard), a sad tale of a 'higgler' (a man who buys and sells from his cart in the villages and farms). Sheila Ruskin, then a demure ingénue, does well as the educated girl whom the young higgler, excellently played by Keith Drinkel, nearly marries. Instead, he catastrophically marries a village girl who becomes a harridan, terrifyingly portrayed by Jane Carr. Eighth: Episode 12, THE RING OF TRUTH. This is a mysterious tale, concerning information conveyed to a young man in a dream by his dead father. By following up on this, the young man finds love and happiness, and learns of his father's secret sorrows. Prunella Scales, as his spoilt and selfish mother, gives an excellent character study. This entire series is a triumph of poignant drama about life as it really was in England a hundred years ago.
robert-temple
This Granada TV series of 1972 made an enormous impact at the time with the more discerning viewers in Britain. I remember how many of our friends stayed in on the relevant evening for weeks because they didn't want to miss it. Those people unfamiliar with country life were in a state of severe shock, as this was a series which showed with a high degree of disturbing realism (as with the shocking film THE MILL) just how basic, gruelling, and relentless country life really was early in the 20th century, long before anything remotely resembling modern society existed. It is astonishing to me that so utterly British a series as this should be available on DVD only in America, and that it has never been released in Britain. The series consisted of 13 episodes, each based on a separate short story by either A. E. Coppard or H. E. Bates. Only 8 of the 13 episodes have been included on the DVD release, and the other 5 are omitted, including BREEZE ANSTEY, which was the episode which made the greatest stir at the time of airing. First: CRAVEN ARMS, starring the young Ian McKellen, who delivers a scintillating performance. At the time he was just a young actor, and we did not know how famous he would become. Nor did it seem odd at the time that he kissed the girls. The story is extremely amusing and satirical, about a young man who simply cannot make up his mind which girl he prefers. Second: THE MILL is a real shocker. Rosalind Ayres is truly brilliant as a 17 year-old girl so simple and naive that she doesn't even know how babies are born. Not for one millisecond does she betray in her eyes the slightest hint of worldly wisdom, and this is one of the most successful portrayals of an innocent I have ever seen. She is spurned by her oafish parents and 'goes into service' in a run-down former mill, where the invalid wife who has the dropsy and is confined to bed is played with hysterical guffaws and sheer brilliance by Brenda Bruce. Bad things happen to poor Rosalind, better left unsaid. This is a brutal story about the harsh realities of life in Derbyshire in 1918. Third: THE SULLENS SISTERS. Here we see a wonderful performance by the young Penelope Wilton, now one of Britain's finest mature actresses. Trevor Bannister, later famous in the TV series ARE YOU BEING SERVED?, has a wonderful opportunity to shine in an over-the-top part, and makes the most of it. The well-known actor Peter Firth, aged 21 and playing 19 successfully, is wonderful as an innocent young boy who falls in love with one sister but when he cannot marry her marries the other instead. The story, set in about 1910, is sharply observed, satirical, and realistic. Fourth: Episode 5 (4 is skipped), THE WATERCRESS GIRL. This features an astonishingly brilliant performance by Susan Fleetwood, who became a famous British TV actress but then died tragically at the age of only 51 in 1995 of ovarian cancer. In this story, set in 1908, Fleetwood plays the only child of a single elderly father in an isolated farmhouse beside a river, where she tends a bed of watercress. She has never seen a town and has rarely spoken with anyone. A young carpenter passing by buys some watercress from her, and a long and tragic love affair ensues, in which she has a dead baby and goes to prison for throwing acid in the face of the man's fiancée. This is an exceptionally grim story of country life in the raw. Fifth: Episode 7, THE LITTLE FARM. This is probably the saddest and most tragic of the stories. It features possibly the most brilliant and inspired performance by Bryan Marshall of his entire career, as the illiterate young farmer who has inherited his remote farm from his mother and lives alone there in squalor. He advertises for a female housekeeper. The entire tragedy of this sad story turns upon Marshall's inability to read, which he cleverly disguises in the way we are all so familiar today with dyslexics. Barbara Ewing is excellent as the unhappy young woman who turns up as the housekeeper, trying to escape her own past, and Michael Elphick is sly and wicked as the neighbour who destroys other people's happiness through selfishness, envy and jealousy. The ending is stomach-turning in its pathos. Sixth: Episode 8, THE BLACK DOG, is a tragic and deeply disturbing tale featuring a central performance by Jane Lapotaire which is profound in its insights into the twisted psychology of a girl who cannot love. The Black Dog is the name of a country pub, run by her father. The story is set in 1912, and a young gentleman played by Stephan Chase falls in love compulsively with the strange and enigmatic Lapotaire. The film is haunting, beautifully done, and extremely upsetting. Seventh: Episode 9, THE HIGGLER. This is one of the best of the stories (by Coppard), a sad tale of a 'higgler' (a man who buys and sells from his cart in the villages and farms). Sheila Ruskin, then a demure ingénue, does well as the educated girl whom the young higgler, excellently played by Keith Drinkel, nearly marries. Instead, he catastrophically marries a village girl who becomes a harridan, terrifyingly portrayed by Jane Carr. Eighth: Episode 12, THE RING OF TRUTH. This is a mysterious tale, concerning information conveyed to a young man in a dream by his dead father. By following up on this, the young man finds love and happiness, and learns of his father's secret sorrows. Prunella Scales, as his spoilt and selfish mother, gives an excellent character study. This entire series is a triumph of poignant drama about life as it really was in England a hundred years ago.
Amy Smith
Country Matters is packaged with lovely, serene photos. Fueled by the title, the mind conjures up pastoral images. I was prepared for a series of Period Piece short films that spoke of love, hate, loss, gain, apathy, greed, and all other such matters related to life everywhere, not just in a country setting.....What I got was several grim, sometimes mean little stories and the sole taste left in my mouth was that of utter cynicism. I wanted to be just in my assessments, and followed through by first actually viewing all of the stories in the two DVD set. Secondly, I truly strived to view these vignettes with an open mind....It is admirable that the authors of these slice-of-life stories strived for realism. I regret, however, that their point of view was quite unbalanced in that the Law of Reciprocity(You know-the reap what you sow thing) seems not to exist in the world of these stories. No one expects the "happy ever after". Again I understand that these are simply vignettes. The nuances of hope, light, and (God forbid, can I say it) redemption are sorely absent from this archival collection. There wasn't a single film in this collection that left me with a desire and or longing to watch it again.
