ScoobyWell
Great visuals, story delivers no surprises
Tedfoldol
everything you have heard about this movie is true.
Aneesa Wardle
The story, direction, characters, and writing/dialogue is akin to taking a tranquilizer shot to the neck, but everything else was so well done.
Yash Wade
Close shines in drama with strong language, adult themes.
Horst in Translation (filmreviews@web.de)
"Werner - Beinhart!" is the first, the best and also the longest movie (90 minutes) from the Werner franchise so far. It runs at least 10 minutes longer, maybe because it also has live action sequences unlike all the films except the most recent fifth installment. The other ones are pretty good though as well, just not as great as this one.25 years have already passed since this got released, wow what a long time. It was a huge commercial success too and that is why there are so many sequels. Besides, a Rumpelstiltskin reference early on, this film features quite a decent cast. Johannes Silberschneider, Ludger Pistor and the very young (maybe 20-year-old) Meret Becker are among Germany's acting elite to this date. The recently-deceased Otto Sander, already famous back then, is the narrator and he reappears in later Werner films too. During the early live action sequences, Brösel basically plays himself a couple 100 years ago how he tries to make the King laugh. Sadly the king has a sickness which won't let him. Bad news for Brösel. However, the animation sequences are the real highlight from the film. The football part early on is pretty great and the plumbing sequence with Mrs. Hansen shortly afterward may be the highlight from the whole Werner franchise. This is also what made Meister Röhrich my favorite from the gang. He is incredibly funny here as is everybody else, including the guy who won't give them the key.Apart from that, the film has some nice music including the very first song already. The humor won't be everybody's cup of tea though. It is vulgar, politically incorrect and includes breasts, vomiting, feces etc. Let me give you one example of a wordplay from this film. There is a judge who is called "H. Odensack", which means literally translated "S. Crotum". But it's much more than that. It may be difficult to see the creative approach at first, but it is certainly there (unlike in films like "Das kleine Arschloch"). Lots of talent in here. If there was one part from the film that did leave me unimpressed, it was probably the very short Neanderthal sequence. And then there is some short funny sequences like the bear Bärbel part for example. Even these are more entertaining than most of the live action sequences. The first half is not as great as the second anymore, but it is not bad either. I thought the hospital sequence was fine. Then there is also a crane sequence and if you know how everything technical in these films turns into disaster, especially with Röhrich nearby, you knew that a huge mess was about to happen.These films are probably not too suitable for children, even if people don't die here. Finally I would also like to mention a hippo/crocodile quote. I'm not sure if this was the purpose, but I had to think of Terence Hill and Bud Spencer immediately. Anyway, great movie and I highly recommend watching it. There are not that many (famous) animated films from Germany, but this is certainly a highlight.
Phoenix Star
First off, you absolutely need to watch this movie in German (with some good knowledge in this language to boot), because A LOT of it will be lost in translation otherwise. It's a specific kind of German humor, one that's definitely not everyone's cup of tea, especially since a couple of scenes involve humongous amount of poop, vomit and other grossities. But underneath it's crude exterior lies a clever exaggeration of real life situations based on the authors, Rötger "Brösel" Feldmann, experience.Take for example when Werner is at work as a heating, air-conditioning and pluming mechanic/installer. I myself have worked in the same field, not the same job, but I've got to know a lot of people that did the same work as the characters and I recognized a lot of traits and mannerism from the movie. There were a lot of stuff going on that immediately felt familiar to me - of course in a exaggerated and comical way. One of the big ones is Meister Röhrich, Werners boss. This is the character that steals the show. The master apparently knows everything better yet is so clumsy that he always ends up causing literally disasters wherever he works at. This alone would be funny enough, but he speaks in a such strange voice and dialect, says a lot of weird job-specific terms, that it's ingenious. And would you know that he is based on a real person that refused to allow them to use his name? Then there is the marketplace and football, the technical review of the choppers, the hospital visit and other every-once-in-a-while situations I'm sure everyone has come across and it's always fun to see with what Brösel comes up with to parody them.As you may already know the movie has parts in it that are not animated and filmed live. These scenes are largely considered to be boring and everyone seems to skip them. To be honest, that's what I did too in the past, but over the time they kinda grew on me. Sure, they are amateurish, the humor consist mostly of burping and catchphrases and they generally pale in comparison to the animated material, but they are fun in a so-bad-its-good way and at least they seem to be self-aware about it. When it comes down to the animation itself, there is little to complain about. It's not as fluent or sharp as e.g. Disney works and even a bit inconsistent and sketchy in the later parts of the movie, but overall just very well executed, with a good sense for physics and a big part why the slapstick in this movie works so well. There always are small things to discover that you didn't notice the first time. It's creative and full of ideas all the time.The voice-acting was superbly done. Everyone fits perfectly and it's hard not to notice the fun the staff had while delivering their lines. Andi Feldmann easily deserves an award for his role as the eccentric Meister Röhrich.Werner: Beinhart is pretty much the movie equivalent of a caricature painting. It's about the small things in real-life but exaggerated in a hilarious and creative manner. It is raw, unconcerned fun and it shows what a real person Rötger Feldmann is. It's just a shame that none of the sequels managed to get even close to it's level.
wernersen
I´m half Dane and half German so i know the language so because of that I understand the movie and I think its great! the animation is crappy but the humor is good. I agree that the scenes that are not animation is boring so i usualy jump over those scenes!
McG
Since the film is divided in animated and real sequences with a tremendous difference in quality, it is very hard to cast a vote that covers both.The animated part is hilarious (especially the football-match) and deserves definitely 8/10 if not better. A must see!The real part is a great opportunity to get a new beer from the refrigerator or to carry the old one to the toilet. It is so boring and unfunny, a 1/10 would be overly gracious.My recommendation is: get it on DVD or Video and skip anything that is not animation.