AniInterview Sorry, this movie sucks

Acensbart Excellent but underrated film

ThedevilChoose When a movie has you begging for it to end not even half way through it's pure crap. We've all seen this movie and this characters millions of times, nothing new in it. Don't waste your time.

Jerrie It's a good bad... and worth a popcorn matinée. While it's easy to lament what could have been...

gavin6942 In a village in Brittany, a young maid and an old woman are spinning while the wind blows threateningly outdoors. In spite of the bad omen, the young maid's boyfriend decides to sail away. Worried, the young maid ask for help to a mysterious old man and his magical crystal ball in order to calm down the rough seas.I happened to really enjoy this film. Sadly, though, what I probably enjoyed the most was the music, which was presumably added much, much later. Regardless, the picture is great, and you have to love the salty seaman. The film was shot at Belle Île and starred local fishermen and lighthouse keepers, adding to their authenticity.Director Jean Epstein is praised regarding this film for the use of "alternative" time measurements in both picture and sound. I have no opinion on that one way or the other.

Horst in Translation (filmreviews@web.de) "Le tempestaire" or "The Storm-Tamer" is a French 20-minute black-and-white short film from shortly after World War II. Jean Epstein made it in 1947, so it will have its 70th anniversary next year and it was one of the last works by this filmmaker. The story revolves around a young and an old woman. The young woman's man decides to go on a dangerous journey and she wants to know how to help him or at least know he is safe from any kind of danger. I personally found it a fairly monotonous watch. The drama did not keep me interested, not even for such a short time, and the characters were too random in my opinion to really care for them, plus we never find out who they really are or what they do. They are just there and we are immediately asked to care for them. That's now how it works. I must say I expected better from Epstein here. Not recommended.

Polaris_DiB This movie has a direct relationship to Man of Aran for it's poetic use of the swirling, pounding, shifting, lucid movements of the sea against the coast, and the human relationship with such a dynamic. Whereas Flaherty's proto-documentary is a celebration of the heroic human against chaos, Epstein's 1947 short is more of a mystical meditation on provincial life.A young woman fears for her boyfriend as he decides to sail out right before a big storm. Despite everyone's efforts to calm her down, she feels ominous about the whole thing and refuses to let go of her anxiety. As the seas rise and the wind howls, she eventually searches for help from the "Tempestaire" (Tempest-tamer) who settles the sea and (instantaneously) brings the boyfriend home.Epstein is rather famous for his avant-garde sensibilities in cinema, and Le Tempestaire shows his supreme talent for building emotion, mood, and tone directly from imagery. This film is somewhat important to his oeuvre because it shows his ability to play with sound, especially in an at-the-time experimental way with fades of noises and a song sung over images of the sea rising.--PolarisDiB

Tryavna Jean Epstein was one of the major figures of the avant-garde movement in French cinema; he even helped train Luis Bunuel early in Bunuel's career. For several decades, Epstein was regarded as one of the great master filmmakers. Sadly, his reputation has fallen off somewhat. No doubt, that is due to a variety of factors: the decline of interest in silent cinema (when Epstein made his most famous movies), the endless parodies that have robbed avant-garde art of some of its power, and the partial break-up (or rearrangement) of the "canon" of great films. Nevertheless, Epstein's reputation remains strong in some circles, especially those who are lucky enough to come across his work. Today, he's probably best known for his free-form, dream-like adaptation of Poe's "Fall of the House of Usher" (1928).In some ways, his much later "Le Tempestaire" may serve as a more approachable introduction to Epstein's work, and I have to confess that it's probably my favorite of his films that I've seen. "Le Tempestaire" is short (around 22 minutes), follows a simple plot, has sound and (French) dialog, and is not based on well-known story. Basically, the story concerns a young woman who lives with her grandmother in a fishing community in Brittany. Following a premonition, the girl tries to persuade her fiancé not to go out to sea in his fishing boat, but the boy ignores her and sets out. Soon, a storm occurs, and the girl frantically tries to find out his fate. Eventually, at the advice of her grandmother, she goes to the titular "Tempestaire," an old man who can supposedly control the weather through the magic power of his crystal ball. It sounds silly, I know, but it's based on authentic folk-lore and is handled poetically rather than literally. At her pleading, the old man agrees to help, and he magically conjures the storm away and the boy suddenly appears. Whether the boy is magically transported home or he simply happened to arrive at the same moment is left unexplained. It's that ambiguity that helps sustain the film's fantasy.Like a lot of self-consciously artistic films, this one takes its time to tell its story -- even though it runs less than half an hour. There are lots of scenes of waves crashing against the coastline, etc. But what makes this movie so powerful is Epstein's self-assured control of his medium. He uses camera tricks (like slow-motion) and experiments with the soundtrack in novel ways for 1947. The end result is an eerie and unsettling film, despite the happy ending. I also suspect that Epstein's skill at handling nonprofessionals and location shooting is largely due to the fact that he had been making several documentary films around Brittany in the years preceding this film. At any rate, "Le Tempestaire" achieves a sense of isolation and fantasy that is quite rare. The closest parallels I can think of are some of the short stories by American "regionalist" authors of New England, like Sarah Orne Jewett's equally unsettling "The Foreigner." If you're interested, this short film is included on Kino's admirable two-disc Avant-Garde DVD collection, along with an array of films by Man Ray, Orson Welles, Dimitri Kirsanoff, Hans Richter, and other notable filmmakers. It serves as a fine and relatively inexpensive introduction to this sort of experimental film-making.