Rijndri Load of rubbish!!

Phonearl Good start, but then it gets ruined

TrueHello Fun premise, good actors, bad writing. This film seemed to have potential at the beginning but it quickly devolves into a trite action film. Ultimately it's very boring.

ActuallyGlimmer The best films of this genre always show a path and provide a takeaway for being a better person.

frenchpublichealth This movie had a few nice elements, like Topher's smarmy and insecure character, and a few nice moments between Fischer and Messina. But, the writing is clunky, the themes tired, and the whole mechanical man metaphor unconvincing and poorly thought out. It had potential, but didn't deliver on any level. In my opinion, it was just a non entity, which is worse than being a bad movie...

marydroy21 I love discovering movies I don't know, and watching them unfold. It doesn't always pay off, but it did with this one. I lerve this movie. So much so I watched it twice. It's the sort of film that you carry around with you for days after. The supporting players were all top notch. Topher Grace is still making my skin crawl, which is a huge compliment to him. Jenna is always charming and relate-able. I was taken by the heart of this story. Chris and Jenna's performances were both endearing, funny and tender. The proverbial misunderstanding was there – girl loses boy, girl gets boy back – but thankfully minimal. It didn't get in the way for me, but it's why I gave the film a 9/10. Chris Messina as Tim is completely original and memorable. Such a great story, moving and quirky, and a little bit haunting in the very best way.

Logan67 The Giant Mechanical Man is the story of Janice and Tim. Janice is trying to successfully navigate her way through life while trying to find herself along the way. The fact that she is past the age where one is supposed to preoccupied with such things and that she has to depend on others for financial support makes the task very difficult. Tim, on the other hand, is trying to successfully navigate his way through life while trying not to lose himself. And finding each other, of course, turns out to be just what each needed. It's not the most original film. It's self-conscious in an indie sort of way, and it depends upon some pretty big plot contrivances. It's also a bit heavy handed. At one point in the film, a character whose birthday is being celebrated gives the following speech while sitting on top of the bar: "It only takes just one person, just one person, to make you feel special, and valid, and like you belong in the world." Well, yeah, but a bit more understatement would have served the film better here and in other places as well. Still, I liked it. Maybe because I never get tired of films about misfits or films that deal with alienation and the struggle to lead authentic lives and form connections with others. It is the most human theme, the only theme, really, and with respect to it, the film has it's heart in the right place.http://manpointing.blogspot.com/2013/07/the-giant-mechanical-man.html

gsjaeger-968-581723 The film is very good at pointing out the shallowness that is often found in everyday life due to pressure to conform to social pressures and to appear positive even in the worst of times, while at the same time pointing out that one's closest relationships can serve as protection from what can feel like the crushing weight of those pressures. It shows the viewer two ways of living and thinking about life, a mainstream one and an "alternative" one. The film has excellent timing, editing, and performances. The cast similarly brings together increasingly well known and lesser know but very talented actresses and actors. A must see indie film!