Interesteg What makes it different from others?

ManiakJiggy This is How Movies Should Be Made

Comwayon A Disappointing Continuation

Beystiman It's fun, it's light, [but] it has a hard time when its tries to get heavy.

TheLittleSongbird Love Merrie Melodie cartoons, and the early ones are always an intriguing watch regardless of whether it works or not. Despite liking music-themed cartoons a lot and having a lot of admiration for particularly Bing Crosby, there was the uncertainty reading the summary as to whether it would be tasteful in execution.'Crosby, Columbo and Vallee' is much more tasteful than one would think reading the summary. It is actually very innocent and good-natured and there is nothing offensive about it. It may not have the best or most eventful of stories, pretty lightweight, it does begin on a stale note, and it's not laugh-a-minute. There is a huge amount to like with 'Crosby, Columbo and Vallee', one will find themselves appreciating Crosby and Rudy Vallee and it will be a good introduction to the now unjustly underrated Ross Columbo.The animation is very nicely done, nice atmospheric shadings, meticulously detailed backgrounds and remarkably smooth drawing for a cartoon so early. The music is full of energy and character, as well as being lushly and cleverly orchestrated. The main song is particularly catchy.Furthermore, 'Crosby, Columbo and Vallee' has a lot of good moments, especially the fire scene and the Vallee impersonation (all the impersonation are on point, but this one in particular). Some of the cartoon is humorous and even more of it is sweet, with some drama and suspense when the fire breaks out.All the characters are fun and endearing. They are well characterised in the voices too.In conclusion, interesting and well done if not one of my favourites. 7/10 Bethany Cox

Robert Reynolds This was a one-shot cartoon done by Harman and Ising for Warner Brothers. There will be spoilers ahead:The title of this short derives from what is essentially a novelty song of the same title, bemoaning the three singers referred to (Bing Crosby, Russ Columbo and Rudy Vallee) and their effect on homes and marriages by being played on the radio and heard in homes across the country.The short actually begins with a group of Indians dancing and singing complainingly about the three. The best bit of business here is when the three names are intoned by animals on a totem pole. Otherwise, the beginning is a bit stale.The short then shows an Indian brave paddling a canoe in the best extended bit of animation to be found in the short. The brave plays the type of role later taken on by the character of Buddy, who was developed after Harman and Ising left Warner Brothers and took Bosko with them. In other words, he's as bland as dry toast.There's a long sequence in the middle of the short where the brave is trying to win the heart of Minnehaha with the help of a radio and extolling the virtues of the three singers. While there are some decent bits here, the cartoon simply marks time until the five minute mark, when a fire starts and some flames break loose and start burning trees. There's a cute bit with a tree shown in its underwear after the flames burn off its bark.The flames then burn a tree with a nest holding three baby birds, who proceed to chant for help. Heard by the brave, he enlists the aid of some flies to bring a spider web over to serve as a net to catch the birds in when they jump. The end is reasonably cute.This short is worth seeing.

theowinthrop This is an amusing old cartoon I saw twenty or so years ago. An Indian tribe has a problem - the woman all love Bing Crosby, Rudy Vallee, and Ross Columbo (three of the four leading crooners of the 1920s into the 1940s, with Al Jolson probably being the fourth). Now, some seventy seven years later, the cartoon probably raises questions among the young watching it: they might recall Crosby, who had a great movie career (with or without his pal Bob Hope) copped by an Oscar, as well as a leading singing career - best known for "White Christmas". They can possibly be aware of Rudy Vallee due to his performances in some film, culminating in his repeating his stage triumph as "J. P. Biggley" in HOW TO SUCCEED IN BUSINESS WITHOUT REALLY TRYING, but it is hard for me to believe they would recall his megaphone antics with songs like, "There is a tavern in the town" or "The Wippenproof Song". By the end of the 1930s, while still popular he was nowhere near Crosby in popularity.Columbo is the real problem. Most of his songs are long forgotten (except by his fans of course), and he is best recalled for his bizarre death (shot "accidentally" (?) by a very close male friend shortly after announcing his engagement to actress Carole Lombard). Whether it was murder of not, it is his taking off that most people recall. It's too bad, because he was a good singer, and quite handsome. He might have gone as far as Crosby.The little jingle tune in honor of the three (with the singer doing imitations of them in the course of the song) is what I most recall from this cartoon. It was not a great song, but it was lively. So was the animation, leading up to a forest fire, and the rescue of a nest of birds. It is a sweet cartoon - of a somewhat gentler time in our culture.

tavm Just watched this Harmon-Ising Merrie Melodies cartoon for producer Leon Schlesinger in association with Warner Bros. on YouTube. It's basically a musical one with American Indians (or Native Americans if you want to be PC) singing the title song as to what the public was crazy about music-wise during this period. Nice dancing movements abound and there are some amusing gags near the end concerning fire, trees, birds, and the way the fire gets put out. There are also uncanny impersonations of Crosby and Vallee. So on that note, this cartoon is worth a look. P.S. Since this was the early '30s, the familiar Warner Bros. cartoon characters like Porky Pig, Bugs Bunny, and Daffy Duck have yet to be created. If the animal character designs seem a little close to what the Walt Disney animation looked like at the time, that's because Hugh Harmon and Rudy Ising had originally worked for Uncle Walt in the '20s before leaving just as a certain mouse made Walt famous...