Protraph Lack of good storyline.

Edwin The storyline feels a little thin and moth-eaten in parts but this sequel is plenty of fun.

Bob This is one of the best movies I’ve seen in a very long time. You have to go and see this on the big screen.

Cody One of the best movies of the year! Incredible from the beginning to the end.

a_baron As might be inferred from its name, this is a comedy, or was meant to be. Unfortunately it isn't that funny, even for those of us who have some familiarity with the nuances of urban black life in the America of this time, if only from similar films."Cotton Comes To Harlem" is also a thriller, and it would have made better viewing if this aspect had been played up, which would have entailed playing down the comic book violence. The bottom line is that $87,000 is stolen in a blatant robbery, and law enforcement including two black detectives turn Harlem upside down in pursuit of it. That sum was worth considerably more then than in today's money, but not so much this was the Great Train Robbery of New York State. The cotton reference is not an allusion to de old plantation but to the stolen money somehow ending up in a bale of cotton.One of the detectives is played by Godfrey Cambridge who just six years later was dead from a heart attack at just 43. This film does not make a good epitaph for him or for anyone else.

chaos-rampant Although Shaft/Sweet Sweetback are usually credited as the blaxploitation movies that kickstarted the funky genre, Cotton Comes to Harlem from one year earlier deserves that honour. A suitably entertaining action/comedy romp that has a great first half hour which it never quite manages to equal again. Of note is that the villain is a black corrupt preacher type and not whitey. Ossie Davis combines some great lines with cool music, some nice location shots of Harlem that add an air of guerilla authenticity, a freewheeling car chase, a junkyard shootout and good ole fisticuffs. It's never boring but some scenes are better than others, as if two different movies (one good, one average) are duking it out and the result is a draw.

MartinHafer This is a decent and very watchable film--the first so-called "blaxploitation" film. However, this label is hard to apply to this film because although it has many of the sensibilities (stupid White cops as well as gratuitous nudity), it also features some things you never or rarely see in this genre. First, the heroes of this film are Black cops (Coffin and Gravediffer)--and cops are NOT leading men in blaxploitation films! Second, one of the biggest scumbags in the film is a Marcus Garvey-like Black con-man, the Rev. Deke O'Malley. So instead of trying to pigeonhole this film into this genre, I'd rather just judge it by itself.The film has an excellent R&B score--one of the better ones of the era. The acting by all was very good, though Godfrey Cambridge came off the best of the lot. Direction by veteran actor Ossie Davis was also pretty good.One serious complaint is that the film doesn't seem to know, at times, whether it's a comedy or drama--I wish it had stuck a little closer to one or the other. The other problem is that while the movie was definitely intended to appeal to Black audiences, it could have resounded well with all audiences if they'd let up a little on the negative attitudes towards Whites--though, back in 1970, I could certainly understand all the anger, resentment and mistrust. Heck, had I been Black back then, I'm pretty sure I would have hated White folks as well. It's too bad really, as because of this most non-Black audiences would miss out on seeing a good film.By the way, the movie makes a couple references to Marcus Garvey. The Reverend's character was based on him, though Garvey by almost all accounts did not intend to cheat investors in his Black cruise line. Try reading up on the man--he's one of the most interesting yet forgotten civil rights leaders of the 20th century.

turk_182 Cambridge and St. Jacques are one of all time best buddy cop duos. They are hip, sexy, and funny. The mystery is intriguing, and the uncomfortable situations keep the viewer's attention throughout. This is one to be seen uncut, because a lot of the humor is quite racy. It's a time capsule in a way also since the Harlem depicted here no longer exists.